Che Guevara was not someone to admire

In one classroom at Spring-Ford High School, the teacher has decorated with bumper stickers and posters proclaiming a desire for world peace. Admirable, no doubt. Among the paraphernalia is a very prominent poster of Che Guevara. This may not be a surprise to those who've seen his image plastered everywhere from T-shirts at the mall to Obama campaign headquarters but we need to look at who Guevara was and what he stood for before we hold him up as an example for our children.

According to an article by Jay Nordlinger in the National Review (Dec. 31, 2004), the flourishing Guevara marketers have been making millions while offending Cuban Americans and anyone who is "decent and aware." So who was Che Guevara?

"He was an Argentinian revolutionary who served as Castro's primary thug. He was especially infamous for presiding over summary executions at La Cabana, the fortress that was his abattoir. He liked to administer the coup de grace, the bullet to the back of the neck. And he loved to parade people past El Paredon, the reddened wall against which so many innocents were killed. Furthermore, he established the labor-camp system in which countless citizens — dissidents, democrats, artists, homosexuals — would suffer and die."

As Paul Berman summed up recently in Slate, "Che was an enemy of freedom, and yet he has been erected into a symbol of freedom. He helped establish an unjust social system in Cuba and has been erected into a symbol of social justice. He stood for the ancient rigidities of Latin-American thought, in a Marxist-Leninist version, and he has been celebrated as a freethinker and a rebel."

Those who know, or care about, the truth concerning Guevara are often tempted to despair. The Web site of our own National Institutes of Health describes him this way: "an 'Argentine physician and freedom fighter." Guevara was a physician roughly like Mrs. Ceausescu was a chemist. As for freedom fighter ... again, the temptation to despair is great."

As Mr. Nordling points out, "Imagine being (a Cuban American) and seeing celebratory images of Guevara all around you. Imagine — even further — being the son or daughter of someone whom Guevara personally executed. There are such people in the United States. Or imagine further yet  being a Cuban political prisoner, and knowing that masses in free countries were wearing Che on their chests."

"If you talk to Cuban Americans about how they feel, they will first mention Hitler and the Nazis: No one would sell or sport items celebrating those beasts; what's the difference, other than scale?"

The Spring-Ford district touts a slogan of "Bully free is the way to be." We agree. We need to stop heralding violent criminals as heroes of freedom. We need to educate our children in an environment where the truth matters.

WAYNE HOUCK

Collegeville

Comments

The following are comments from the readers. In no way do they represent the view of pottsmerc.com.

Rick Lee wrote on Nov 10, 2008 8:20 AM:

" This article is a typical uniformed American propaganda piece. Go to Cuba and talk to Cubans if you want facts instead of the nutcase Miami lobby groups.
It is no wonder Americans are ill informed if their press hands them this pap as a "news" item. "

John wrote on Nov 10, 2008 9:27 AM:

" = Right-wing non sense.

Che is a worldwide hero ... and this author is a moron. "

Jorge wrote on Nov 10, 2008 9:29 AM:

" hahahaha

who wrote this drivel ? The CIA

The same Imperialist Amerikkkans who have killed 6,000,000 people since 1950 (see John Stockwell).

I am from Bolivia, and there CHE is seen as a saint, equal to Mary or even Jesus. "

read a book wrote on Nov 10, 2008 9:37 AM:

" "I have yet to find a single credible source pointing to a case where Che executed "an innocent". Those persons executed by Guevara or on his orders were condemned for the usual crimes punishable by death at times of war or in its aftermath: desertion, treason or crimes such as rape, torture or murder."

---- Jon Lee Anderson

author of Che Guevara: A Revolutionary Life (1997), at "The Legacy of Che Guevara" at PBS Online Newshour Forum (20 November 1997) "

Carlos wrote on Nov 10, 2008 9:43 AM:

" "This secular saint (Che) was ready to die because he could not tolerate a world where the poor of the earth, the displaced and dislocated of history, would be relegated to its vast margins." ~ Ariel Dorfman, Time Magazine "

werd wrote on Nov 11, 2008 4:50 AM:

" George W. Bush is a mass murderer. Richard Cheney is a mass murderer. Che Guevara is a man who participated in a war, which is something Cheney and Bush hid under their mothers' aprons from. "

Viva wrote on Nov 11, 2008 5:40 PM:

" Cuba under the dictator Batista was a Mafia ran Casino (w#ore-house) paradise for idle rich oligarchs and U.$. Companies who owned 70 % of the land and resources.

Batista's secret BRAC police killed over 20,000 people and would gouge the eyes out of political opponents.

This is the context that allowed the heroic Che & Fidel to be victorious in their valiant struggle.

U.S. Sugar, United Fruit Co, Texaco, etc etc were finally overthrown for the first time and the American Empire has made the Cuban people suffer blockade for 50 + years as a result.

Still Cuba stands defiant as a beacon of light for countries who wish to cast off the shackles of U.S. Imperialism & Neocolonial domination.

VIVA CHE !

& I can't wait to see this movie :o) "

roger wrote on Nov 11, 2008 11:04 PM:

" hasta la victoria siempre

if you want peace be ready for war
che......... "

Know the Facts wrote on Nov 13, 2008 6:40 PM:

" The only people who dislike Che Guevera, are people who don't know the facts, and rich Cubans who came to America. All of Cuba's wealth was leaving Cuba and going into the hands of wealthy American's and 5% of the Cuban population. When the Cuban people joined Castro's revolution they wanted to take their country back after being controlled by either the USA or Spain for hundreds of years. There were select Cubans who were very wealthy because they were working with the Americans, but their wealth came at a great cost. The cost was 95% of the Cuban population living in poverty. All the wealthy Cubans fled Cuba to move to the States because they would be subject to punishment for their actions. The reason why Cuba isn't flourishing now is because the United States refuses to trade with them and restricts their allies from trading with Cuba also. The United States is the cause of all Cuba's problems. If they just accepted the fact that they can not take advantage of this country anymore and leaved in a peaceful existance with all of Cuba's problems would be solved. Che Guevara was a necessary part of a successful revolution and is adored by 95% of the Cuban population. "

I wonder if the author is republican wrote on Nov 13, 2008 6:47 PM:

" I like the comments from John (John wrote on Nov 10, 2008 9:27 AM).

Exactly. Right wing moron author. You are sickening. The facts are so clear. When someone gets idealized, and compared to Jesus there is a reason. I know Che has also become a symbol for people who don't know much about him, that is only because he is popular. And those that know what he stood for, and have read his books really adore him. Before you publish an article, do a little more research and maybe you will see your journalism career progress. If you knew the facts I promise you wouldn't feel this way. "

truth wrote on Nov 13, 2008 10:31 PM:

" Unfortunately, a lie repeated enough often becomes truth for those who have no need for facts and rely on emotions. The fact is Che was a mass murder and not all rich Cubans fled to the U.S. As the Cubans who left on the Muriel Boat Lift what they know of Che. They left Cuba, not because they were rich but because they wanted freedom. A very close friend of mine is such a man and he and his parents experienced what Che did. It is a disgrace that the Spring Ford School District allows this garbage in classrooms. What next, a picture of Bin Ladin? Some call him a freedom fighter also. How sad that a teacher is so uninformed. No wonder our schools are in such trouble. "

Alfredo wrote on Nov 14, 2008 12:00 AM:

" Ernesto "Che" Guevara was a terrorist. He killed a lots of Cuban people at the beginning of the Cuban Revolution in 1959. Thanks to the bolivian Army this crazy man is death. He is not a Saint, he is a criminal like his partner Fidel Castro. Communist destroyed my country and we, the Cubans are all around the world because his stupid revolution "

Mirtha wrote on Nov 14, 2008 12:07 AM:

" Che Guevara was a criminal like Bin Laden, Saddan Hussein, Fidel Castro and Hugo Chavez. For many Americans and for our new President Barack Obama he is a hero. Americans made a big mistake, now we will pay for that "

Matt wrote on Nov 14, 2008 7:41 AM:

" Rick Lee: "Go to Cuba and talk to Cubans if you want facts instead of the nutcase Miami lobby groups."

Really? Because the Cubans still living under their oppressive communist system would be more honest than those who risked their lives to float here on tires? Are you the same guy who wanted to interview scientists in Iraq with someone from the Iraqi government standing right behind them? Count your blessings you live in the United States, but maybe you oughta' get out of Pottstown once in a while.

Know the Facts: "Rich Cubans who came to America"

Really? Because it looks to me like anyone who can find anything that'll float is looking to escape your communist paradise. What do you think would happen if China was only 80 miles away? "

Pablo wrote on Nov 14, 2008 1:25 PM:

" To all americans liberals: TRY TO LIVE IN CUBA.....Cuba needs FREEDOM, respect of HUMAN RIGHTS, FREE ELECCTIONS, FREEDOM OF ALL POLITICAL PRISONERS and DEMOCRACY...This is the legacy of Che Guevara "

SF Resident disappointed with school wrote on Nov 14, 2008 4:01 PM:

" As usual all of the liberal dingbats seem to get there way. Che was an outright terrorist along with dictator Fidel Castro. Continue the embargo until the people of Cuba overthrow the current government. I get sick and tired of politically correct chatter. Che was a murderer, thief, and a thug. "

Alejandro wrote on Nov 14, 2008 8:29 PM:

" "Che was the most complete human being of our time ... our era's most perfect man." ---- JEAN PAUL SARTRE "

Mary wrote on Nov 14, 2008 10:35 PM:

" Isn't it amazing that when confronted with facts, the left always reverts to name calling. If they had any integrity, they would READ. Reading is more than words, intelligent people read between the lines, question, confirm. To Read a Book, why don't you read "Exposing the Real Che Guevara" by Humberto Fontova? My friend and his family escaped Cuba during the Muriel Boat Lift. They didn't leave because they were rich, in fact, no one in Cuba is rich except for the Castro brothers and their cronies. It is sad that these same people who love Che are the same type who deny the holocost! Is the United States the only country Cuba can trade with. Think! Castro has the whole world with which to trade. Cuba is a failure because of the failed communist experiment begun by Castro and his minion Che, the butcher. It is hard to believe that these lies about Che, the hero, continue even with all the evidence to the contrary. The same mentality of the Che supporters is evident in Iran's president and his deniel of the holocost in sharp contrast to the facts. "

Hasta Siempre wrote on Nov 15, 2008 3:08 AM:

" Che fought against U.S. imperialism which enslaved 100,000,000 of his fellow Latin Americans into a system of oligarchy and subservience.

A system of tin pot U.$. backed dictators, banana repiblics, right-wing deaths squads, and U.$. Corporate sponsored torture chambers.

For that valiant struggle CHE will always be remebered as a HERO of LATIN AMERICA <3

Hasta la Victoria Siempre! "

read wrote on Nov 15, 2008 3:10 AM:

" CHE: "The life of a single human being is worth a million times more than all the property of the richest man on earth. Much more definitive and much more lasting than all the gold that one can accumulate is the gratitude of a people." (‘On Revolutionary Medicine’, 1960) "

Login To Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
 

Not Registered? Sign up today for free!

Do not use usernames or passwords from your financial accounts!

Note: Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required!

*Create a Member ID:
*Choose a password:
*Re-enter password:
*E-mail Address:
*Year of Birth:
 

(children under 13 cannot register)

*First Name:
*Last Name:
Company:
Home Phone:
Business Phone:
*Address:
*City:
*State:
*Zip Code:
 

Jobs Homes Autos

Marketplace

Browse print ads, find online deals, and search valuable coupons from local retailers!

Place An Ad, Special Sections, Classifieds

National AP Headlines

View all AP National Headlines

Blog Center

Scene & Heard

Where The Mercury's music junky dissects life and entertainment.

Talking Politics with Tony Phyrillas

Conservative politics blog by Tony Phyrillas.

alt

Daily Overload

The editor of The Mercury writes about the trials and tribulations -- and joys -- of putting out a daily newspaper, and about the team of people that makes it happen.

alt

Photo Files

The best photos of the past week from The Mercury

More Blogs